REPEAT! Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Take the 2026 SCN Halloween Candy Showdown

Kids trick or treating at Halloween.
(Image credit: Getty Images)

It's a wrap. Like last year when No. 10-seed Reese's Peanut Butter Cups took it all, the Butter Cups again rose victorious. They bullied their way through the bracket, winning each of their four victories by an average margin of 47.5 points per game (points are percentages of votes, not total votes!).

"There may be no wrong way to eat a Reese's," head coach P.B. Cups said, "but there is only one way to celebrate. And that is with the Butter Cups back on top again."

The final battle was between the only two champions in SCN Halloween Candy Showdown history. The 2024 champs, Snickers, were looking good heading into the championship game, but even their nougat, caramel, and roasted peanuts covered in milk chocolate was no contest for the Cups. They lost by 30 points.

"Mmmmmm.... chocolate," a drooling Homer Simpson said court side, waving a brown flag.

Thank you again for voting. Have a Happy Halloween and keep scrolling for the sweet recap of this year's tournament.

2026 Bracket

The SCN Halloween Candy Showdown 2026 final bracket.

(Image credit: Future)

Final Four

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups continued their utter domination, taking down tournament first-timer, Baby Ruth by a score of 72-28. It is seemingly becoming too easy for the Butter Cups, as they have now won six in a row dating back to last years tournament.

"Baby Ruth had its time to shine," said P.B. Cups, head coach of Reese's. "Whether it was the Great Bambino, Grover Cleveland's daughter, or Sloth... well, as they said in Goonies, 'it's our time.'

The Butter Cups have the Cinderella of the ball up next as No. 13 100 Grand bar pulled off another lopsided upset. "It's time for those Butter Cups to pay," said the Grand's head coach.

The other half of the semifinals pits 2024 national champion Snickers against another upset special in Twizzlers. Snickers barely advanced against another longtime powerhouse in M&Ms. "I've said it before, and I'll say it again," Snickers' head coach said, "we're not going anywhere for a while."


Elite Eight

We are on to the final eight teams remaining. Defending champion Reese's Peanut Butter Cups cruised to the largest victory, defeating its Reese's brethren, the Pieces, by the largest margin of victory in the first round. "Tip of the hat to Reese's Pieces," a representive from the Peanut Butter Cups said in a postgame press conference. "There simply is no wrong way to eat a Reese's, but today, it was decided there just may be."

The 2024 champion, Snickers, also barreled through the first round. Of course, this time of year, we all love the upset specials, and we had a few in the first round. No. 10 M&Ms took down No. 7 Almond Joy quite convincingly (79-21), setting up a rematch of the 2025 semifinals. Perhaps the big surprise was No. 13 100 Grand with the commanding 63-37 victory over No. 4 Butterfinger, a 2025 final four team just one year ago. "Guess we laid a finger on that Butterfinger," head coach Rich Moneybags. "Just couldn't compete with our fortune of flavor."

It is the third time M&Ms and Snickers have made it this far. They are the only two squads to make the Elite Eight every year of the SCN Halloween Candy Showdown.

How It Works

It is pretty simple. Each round will pit two candies against each other. The winner will be decided by your vote. How do you vote? It will be right near the top of our SCN SmartBrief Monday through Friday, beginning on Oct. 8 and concluding on Oct. 29. The winner will be announced on Oct. 30.

Not subscribed to our newsletter and want your voice heard? Well, that's an easy fix. Click here to subscribe today!

Wayne Cavadi
Senior Content Manager

Wayne Cavadi is the senior content manager of Systems Contractor News. Prior to taking a leap into the Pro AV industry, Wayne was a journalist and content lead for Turner Sports, covering the NCAA, PGA, and Major and Minor League Baseball. His work has been featured in a variety of national publications including Bleacher Report, Lindy's Magazine, MLB.com and The Advocate. When not writing, he hosts the DII Nation Podcast, committed to furthering the stories and careers of NCAA Division II student-athletes.