The Revolution Will Not be Televised in 3D by Virginia Rubey -

The Revolution Will Not be Televised in 3D by Virginia Rubey

Publish date:

As 3D product promoters hail 3D as a revolutionary technology, one notable industry pro says he is “hopeful it will die a very quick death... for several reasons.” AVT uncovers both sides of this 3D story, and considers a solution both sides have overlooked.

On the eve of 3D TV’s release, AVT projected the technology’s impact on tech managers would be minimal. As of September 2010, we stand by our earlier evaluation: despite shouts and murmurs that a 3D revolution is here, the technology has yet to prove it’s a cause worth fighting for.

Realistic evaluations for 3D ROI is bound to burst a few bubbles, but the discussion of unlikely possibilities for applying 3D technology has proved riveting.In an interview with Computerworld, Marthin De Beer, Senior Vice President at Cisco’s Emerging Technologies Group, shared Cisco’s vision for applying 3D technology to videoconferencing, telepresence forums, and holography: "Someday we can sit around a virtual table and you will be able to walk around behind somebody and see the back of his head, but he will actually be thousands of miles away,” he said. “It's coming.”

AV pros are passionate and laud the revolutionary vision, but pro investment in “someday” projects depends on the availability of efficient products. For all the buzz, 3D products have not hit the market with a bang.

A 3D capable system requires a 3D display; a 3D adapter for HDMI 1.4a signal conversion; a 3D emitter; 3D eyewear; and a 3D source device. As AVT reported in April, 3D content is still at a deal-breaking minimum, although 3D hardware producers (still) insist that will change.

There has been some progress toward navigable 3D systems packaging and 3D content offerings this summer: DIRECTV launched a 3D satellite receiver package that includes four 3D-dedicated channels (three of which broadcast “pay per view” or “on Demand” programs for $6.99 each), while Mitsubishi debuted its 75-inch LaserVue 3D-ready HDTV alongside a 3D Starter Pack in July.

So what do 3D consumers get, and what do they pay for? Use the chart below as your guide:

3D Hardware Requirements Product Price Range
 3D TV$1,100 (50-inch Plasma, 1080p) - $5,999+ (75-inch Laser TV, 1080p)
 3D Adapter
 $100 - $300 3D Eyewear with DLP Link or Matching Emitter (IR, RF, Bluetooth) $115 - $400+ (excluding battery replacement cost) 3D Satellite Receiver
 $199 for new DIRECTV customers + $10 monthly access charge + $6.99 content cost per program 3D Blu-ray player
 $150 - $450 3D Desktop Gaming System (excluded from total cost figures) $1400 - $6700 TOTAL COST FOR 3D
$1,785 - $7,470excluding the cost of DIRECTV pay per view content; 3D Blu-ray discs; 3D eyewear battery replacements and cost of multiple sets; and 3D gaming system options

Mitsubishi’s Starter Pack includes a 3D Adapter (HDMI 1.4a to checkerboard conversion); 2 pairs of 3D eyewear; and a matching emitter for $399. Additional eyewear must be compatible with your 3D system. At $115-$400 a pair, you may need to rethink the guest list for your Super Bowl party - or settle for HD.

Technologists appreciate innovative industry visions, but 3D technology does not - yet -offer a sight as spectacular as its price. How immersive is a 75-inch 3D screen set against a 20-foot white wall when you’re wearing clunky glasses and holding the Blu-ray, DIRECTV, and display remotes? The manufacturers’ strong recommendation that viewers watch 3D content from a distance triple the size of the screen is another complication.

The viewer distance recommendation is warranted, nonetheless. Though complaints can get lost amid the marketing buzz, some consumers have called 3D “a headache,” and no wonder: 3D product warnings acknowledge the risk of epileptic seizures; strokes; altered vision; lightheadedness; dizziness; involuntary twitching; confusion; nausea; loss of awareness; convulsions; cramps; motion sickness; perceptual aftereffects; eye strain; poor posture; headaches; fatigue; and disorientation.

You don’t have to worry about watching too much 3D TV: YouTube videos notwithstanding, 3D content limitations are frustrating for the most avid of Avatar fans, and while 3D product manufacturers insist more 3D content is coming soon, it may be too soon for some. Content producers already struggle with rising production costs amid plummeting ad sales, and accommodate SD, HD, SAP & MPEG-4 formats. With a successful SD to HD migration still underway, 3D TV is a poorly articulated interruption for producers, and an unwelcome jab for consumers who just invested in an HD entertainment system.

Producers also point to a potentially fatal flaw in 3D-dedicated productions: the excitement that fuels industry innovation could spur a technology that will detract from, rather than enhance, a story.

Paul Parrie, Associate Vice President of Information Systems & Technology at the National World War II Museum, put together one of the most impressive state of the art theaters with his team this year. The seasoned AV pro acknowledges, “If you can’t tell a story with cuts and dissolves, you’re not a very good producer - or your story isn’t very good.”

Are we really investing in 3D for the sake of feeling close to Brangelina in the sequel to Mr. & Mrs. Smith?

AV pros are discussing a bigger picture. There are industries where 3D technology may be a better fit: hospitality centers, college admissions offices, disparate offices and property & product dealers could enhance efficiency and user experience with 3D tours, presentations, and meetings. The ROI would, of course depend on the degree to which consumers adopt of 3D-ready systems, but if 3D video quality evolves into a sufficient replacement for college visits, saved travel expenses could offset the cost of 3D system hardware!

At this stage in 3D tech’s evolution, that revolution is a long way away.

If we learned anything from the first 3D “revolution,” we learned that successful 3D tech requires more R&D than enthusiasts have been willing to utter aloud. Sky-high consumer product costs may not be a sustainable strategy to support 3D tech development, but companies like SENSIO, Cisco, and Magnetic 3D are thinking beyond the 75-inch box.

SENSIO turned heads during FIFA’s 2010 World Cup in South Africa with 4,500 live 3D screenings at 700 theaters in 33 countries, and Magnetic 3D debuted auto-stereoscopic (glasses-free) 3D displays and digital signage solutions through “Suites of the Future” at Sun Life Stadium in February.

The SENSIO 3D Live Global Network provides an online schedule of local 3D events and affordable ticket purchasing options, which sounds a lot like IMAX... but looks a lot better than the 3D options consumers can install at home.

For more 3D updates, check out AVT’s coverage of CAVE Automatic Virtual Environment

Virginia Rubey is a New Orleans-based video journalist and educator.



Expectations vs Reality for 3D by Virginia Rubey

by Virginia Rubey January’s Consumer Electronics Show got everyone buzzing about 3D TVs after Panasonic, Toshiba, Vizio, Samsung, LD, Sony, and others announced plans to release 3D-capable televisions by summer 2010. But with limited 3D content and expensive, burdensome requirements, consumers are hardly rushing out

iPhone 4: WWTC? by Virginia Rubey

The iPhone 4.0 Post-WWDC, AVT answers WWTC: What would a tech pro choose?      Check out our run-down of iPhone 4.0 features. Then take AVT’s quiz to decide for yourself. FACT: Two cameras let Wi-Fied iPhone 4 users video chat with a front-facing camera via Apple’s “Face Time” software, and simultaneously stre

Ten iPad Apps for AV Managers by Virginia Rubey

When “iPad” first hit the headlines, Kleiner Perkins invested $100 million in iPad app building startups. Consumers were hit by higher eBook prices across the board. Colleges like Seton Hill and George Fox decided to grant freshmen an iPad in the Fall. If the game is changing, what’s your position? AV Technology m

Why Follow Us on Twitter? by Virginia Rubey

If you’re an AV technology manager, you probably already have a subscription to AV Technology magazine. You read our digital edition before the hard copy arrives at your office. AVT Online is your homepage. You subscribe to the RSS feed of the AVT blog for daily equipment, trend, and industry updates. So, do yo

AVT’s Top 10 iPad Apps for Tech Managers by Virginia Rubey

As app developers advance iPad options, AVT researchers are keeping AV pros ahead of the game. Here's our Summer Most Wanted List. KEY: Look for the + symbol to identify universal apps. P+ indicates universal compatibility, with an iPad-specific app option Apps marked CS will be available later this year.

Product Review: Kodak’s Zi8 by Virginia Rubey

    If you’ve ever been on a support call with a client - or if you are a client - who refers to a port or touchscreen icon as a “thingy,” you can appreciate the ROI of simple equipment support and troubleshooting videos. Kodak’s Zi8 Pocket Video Camera is the   low cost, high performance solution for tech managers w

How Viable is AV Outsourcing? by Virginia Rubey

As another Cell Phone Civil War battle plays out this week in Wisconsin, AVNetronics is looking at the bigger picture of AV ventures. The worldwide consulting company claims it is the first AV outsourcing point that cultivates “reverse outsourcing” relationships. It brokers deals between North American AV companies an

Droid X: What Tech Managers Need to Know by Virginia Rubey

The Smartphone sensation has produced mobile technology options that are smarter, faster, and stronger than ever. Apple’s iPhone is stable at the top of sales charts, but discontented consumers have called attention to the unstable reception of the newest model - or at least they have tried. Amid disappointment at