The Changing Digital Signage Market

The Changing Digital Signage Market

NEW SUPPLY CATEGORY IN THE DIGITAL SIGNAGE INDUSTRYDigital Signage Business System Providers (DS-BSP) Offer Option to End Users

Changes in the

digital signage supply chain are occurring as the industry matures. A new category of supplier, the digital signage business systems provider (DSBSP) has emerged as end user confidence and the application of digital signage has grown in North America. This new supplier group operates in a key point of partnership with organizations that represent a significant new user base for digital signage.

This new supply category has emerged in response to better informed end users, typically those that have assessed supply options and grasped the complexity of designing, deploying, and operating a digital signage network. The growth of the BSP category is being driven by end users that seek turnkey systems comprising all elements of the DS ecosystem, while providing some content, technology sourcing, and operating infrastructure themselves. Such end users will buy the technologies and want full control of the content presented. They do not wish to carry advertising.

The DS-BSP is like the general contracting firm that places its billboard on a vacant piece of commercial land advertising that they will “design and build to suit.”

Steve Harris, VP business development of Digital Display and Communications (DDC), a BSP, notes that “organizations engage us to provide their digital signage network based on our experience in applying the medium and our ability to supply objective technology recommendations, ongoing network operations, content, and continuous improvement. Our approach to digital signage is to clearly explore and define our client’s overall business objectives first, leading us to the development of a sustainable content strategy. Then, we are able to source the most suited, ‘best of breed’ technology to finalize system design and operational structure.

“The end users that reach us have typically shopped widely or experienced internal operations of their network on limited scale,” he adds. “Sometimes end users don’t immediately see the value of using a managed service provider until after they have had limited success trying to implement and manage a digital signage network in-house”.


The Whitlock Group designed and installed a sophisticated digital signage system at Virginia Commonwealth University that included an important security aspect, with the ability to instantly message students — including on cell phones. The Whitlock Group is the kind of full-service systems integrator that is changing the way digital signage systems are launched and managed. increasingly recognized as a highly costeffective and empowering communications device, this characterization of end users increasingly applies.

Rachel Milan, marketing director of the Teachers Credit Union reflects the views of many end users in pointing out that their marketing department is small and is not in the business of digital signage. “Digital signage works,” says Milan, “and by using DDC as a full service provider, we have been able to benefit from having and using digital signage as part of our marketing and staff communications, where it might not otherwise have been possible, or as effective.”

In presenting a case study of the staff communications network deployed at NAVSEA during the recent Strategy Institute/Infocomm08 Digital Signage Technology Summit, Pat Dolan, deputy director, Naval Sea Systems Command Office of Corporate Communication, who oversaw the network project, says, “Having the combination of technology expertise and communications experience has been critical to our successful application of digital signage.” She also notes that a full-service provider can be very helpful in moving a project forward more quickly within an organization, because they can provide informed commentary on all areas of the planned deployment.

In some cases, existing digital signage infrastructure and internal projects are being integrated into new supply relationships where the BSP provides a full-service package of project [18] DIGITAL SIGNAGE MAGAZINE NEW SUPPLY CATEGORY IN THE DIGITAL SIGNAGE INDUSTRY Digital Signage Business System Providers (DS-BSP) Offer Option to End Users BY LYLE BUNN THE CHANGING DIGITAL SIGNAGE MARKET “A full-service provider can move a project forward more quickly within an organization.” design, system enhancement and ongoing operations that include network operations, creative, and playlist administration services.

Typically, providers of hardware (displays, servers, etc), software, or connectivity have been a primary respondent to end user interest in digital signage. Many Requests for Proposal are still issued to technology providers by end users.


In the past several years other supply options have emerged. In “old west land-grab” fashion, many signage network operators and service providers have established location agreements to gain high-traffic venue access for the new enterprise to offer networks that integrate thirdparty advertising sales with technology integration and network operations. Some industry association websites, such as and, reflect that 56 network operators have established adbased, arm’s length supply “partnerships” to provide about 425,000 displays in 36,000 locations through retailers, property managers, transit systems, health service providers, hospitality facilities, and so on. Beyond these 56 network operators, which tend to be national in geographic scope, many other ad-based networks exist, including smaller and local or regional networks, sometimes serving just a single location. The reported total number of ad-based networks varies from 100 to 1000 in North America.

More recently, system integrators and [20] DIGITAL SIGNAGE MAGAZINE THE CHANGING DIGITAL SIGNAGE MARKET The Whitlock Group designed and installed a sophisticated digital signage system at Virginia Commonwealth University that included an important security aspect, with the ability to instantly message students — including on cell phones. The Whitlock Group is the kind of full-service systems integrator that is changing the way digital signage systems are launched and managed. DS BUSINESS SYSTEM PROVIDER Example firms DDC;; John Ryan Inc.; Vox Optima Primary end-user objective Improve branding; Staff or patron information; Support communications goals Governing structure with end user Supply and service agreement Profitability source Service fees and margins on technology sales Technology positioning Agnostic Relationship to end user Partnership with co-management of DS network Owner of network No 3rd Party Advertising Typically Not TABLE 1 commercial AV providers have become part of the digital signage supply mosaic based on their ability to successfully integrate the many moving parts of hardware, software, connectivity, and needed services that comprise the digital signage ecosystem. Their technology “solution” has typically been provided to end users or network investors. Ingram Micro, The Digital Signage Group, and members of the USAV Group such as Multi-media Solutions and Nor-Com offer good examples.

Jeff McDowell, who leads employee communications for Procter & Gamble’s health care businesses worldwide, says, “We have dramatically improved how P&G communicates with its more than 4500 employees across its global health care businesses. As part of these efforts, P&G installed a robust digital signage system throughout its 1.6-million-square-foot global health care headquarters located just north of Cincinnati, Ohio. Our selection of a digital signage supplier was based on our confidence in the supplier’s abilities and their knowledge of the P&G culture, organization, and environment”.

System integrators that can demonstrate their capabilities to integrate DS into the end users communications plan and provide services following technology deployment will become business system providers. The motivation of an ongoing client relationship, recurring revenues, and profits from sources other than product mark-up suggest that system integrators could become a significant force in DS supply, and a big part of the BSP category. There is clear evidence of this direction by forward thinking commercial audiovisual providers and systems integrators, with industry associations such as InfoComm International offering training and other programs to accelerate this development.

As a growing giant, the supply category of digital signage business system provider has its roots in systems integration, business communications services, vertical market business growth consulting, or as a network operator. Such firms have typically low profile. They work under confidentiality agreements while sourcing technology, are highly targeted in generating new clients, operate in multiple market verticals, and rarely exhibit at trade shows, present at conferences or appear in the digital signage media.


Table 1 compares the operating characteristics of the three types of turnkey service providers of digital signage. Providers of displays, servers, DS software, connectivity, installation, mounts, and other hardware, software, and services are well served by the growth of this new supply category. Digital signage business system providers are close to end users, can select the right technology for the requirement, and accelerate projects while helping assure their success.

Systems integrators are provided a growth path that can increase their revenues and margins, leverage sales investment to improve revenue-per-client, and improve their supplier/client relationship.

The big winner is the end user. As digital signage is increasingly seen as a very valuable enterprise communications tool, meriting internal budget, the ability to source digital signage easily, with low risk and to maximum application benefit, will benefit the end user above all.

The emergence of the DS-BSP as a new supply category reflects the growth and maturation of North America’s digital signage industry, and the desire on the part of the industry to meet market demands in ways that provide value and maximize end user and project success.

As strategy architect and principal of BUNN Co., Lyle Bunn ( provides strategic and business counsel to investors, operators, suppliers, and users of digital signage and dynamic out-of-home media. He is deeply rooted in the planning processes, business models, technology integration, and content associated will successful digital signage deployments, having contributed to a broad range of North American deployments in the past six years.