Tough Enough? - AvNetwork.com

Tough Enough?

Author:
Publish date:

In the business of sound and video installation, we've all had our share of working with the tools of the trade -- sound meters, volt meters and design programs. But equally crucial to our everyday existence are tools used in a multitude of industries, like wire strippers and crimpers. Selecting the latter type of tools can be as complex a task as any system design. Time and time again, we hear about the "great" new crimper and the $100 must-have, all-in-one tool. But what we don't hear is whether these tools will make money or drain resources. If you have a shop with three guys in the field, and two of them are wasting valuable time fiddling with inadequate or broken tools, then you know what I mean.

This is why it's so important to make the right choice about one tool in particular. You know, the one that you use on every job site for the mundane tasks of hanging brackets, flying speakers, assembling racks of gear and punching holes: cordless power drills. Yes, we're talking about those marvels of invention that you praise when they work and curse when you have to wait two hours to charge a battery.

In this field review, we will examine various models of 9.6-, 12-, 14.4- and 18-volt cordless drills, along with the big bad boys, the hammer drills, which rival or surpass anything wired out there today. Hopefully with these insights, you'll be able to avoid the desperation experienced when a drill breaks on a job site.

Today the selection of battery powered drills is quite extensive, with at least six models from at least six manufacturers in at least four different voltages, with two different chuck sizes and a wide range of accessories. On-site or in-house, when the tool dies or the battery explodes and you say, "Get me whatever is on sale in a 9.6 volt," you are making the wrong choice, and it will cost you more in the long-run. Choosing the appropriate voltage and torque for your needs is paramount to efficiency and is cost-effective. Next comes the ergonomic feel of a drill, and how durable it is, followed by power needed, time in use and type of job typically performed

We chose three brands of drills that are readily available, commercially accepted in the trade, and performed well in our tests: Bosch, a German firm, and Delta and Porter Cable, both of which are U.S. operations. Bosch drills examined for this test all were built in Switzerland, with batteries from the Far East, while Delta and Porter Cable drills were constructed mostly in the Far East.

For the test, I evaluated feel, weight, balance, battery charge times, torque and overall comfort in performing specific tasks. I used various models on three separate job sites and in purpose-designed field testing.

First, I assisted in the installation of structured cable throughout a section of a New York Courthouse's very old lathed walls. My tools of choice for the task were hammer drills. First up was a Porter Cable 978 with 23 torque settings plus hammer. Hand feel was very nice, if a tad heavy, with supplied adjustable, replaceable hand grips.

The chucks of today are very different & much better than what you might be used to. The Porter Cable 978 chuck was about 2.5 inches out from the body of what seems to be a high-tensile machined metal, but the real beauty is in the locking action. No more rope burns, just insert, twist and lock. This is true for all models reviewed here from Porter Cable and Bosch.

Next came the Bosch 13614, with 16 torque settings plus hammer. The courthouse walls were no match for these two 14.4V beauties, as they both made mincemeat out of the lathing. Strength like that requires control, and both of these units have a "brake," which allows for precise and immediate stoppage of motion.

On this test, both seemed equally matched in strength, with hand grip comfort going to Porter and trigger grip and control going to Bosch. Both units include optional second-hand control arm for hammer use, and the Bosch has user-replaceable brushes for the motor. Both drills worked extremely fast and saved valuable time on a Saturday.

For my second test, I installed a new LCD projector. This time I would be drilling into reinforced concrete approximately 15 years of age. First up was the 14.4V Bosch 32614, a 3/8-inch chuck version without a hammer feature using the same battery as the 13614. Oh, the beauty of balance! This unit is perfect for racking gear, driving screws and overall use. Working overhead in this case, the difficulty of vertical drilling became apparent after the first inch or so of concrete. So out came models 978 and 13614 again. First up was the Porter Cable, which worked admirably up to the point of the bit failing and my shoulder yelling "Stop." I then installed an industrial hammer drill bit from Bosch Industrial, which made the next hole a 30-second breeze. Switching then to the Bosch 13614, we noticed what seemed to be more torque, as both remaining holes of about 3 inches in depth drilled out in just over 20 seconds.

The third task was done from the vantage point of an observer. I loaned the two beasts of the group to an electrician installing a box in what turned out to be very stubborn, hard and crumbly concrete. Of course this never happens to AV installers when flying speakers somewhere in a stadium or hundred year-old church, trying to drill a 3/8-inch hole and getting 9/16 of an inch! Must have been that wobbly chuck right? Wrong.

Six holes were drilled, in the same building where a certain wired drill of unmentioned industrial variety was used throughout the job prior. First used was a Bosch 13618 loaded with 18V of 2.4Ah power, 16 torque settings plus hammer, and enough torque to rival anything with a wire attached to a 15-amp line. From the start, the drill has the same industrial feel and build of the model 13614, but this time the battery comes from Japan. A full metal, internal collar ads to the durability, especially when the tool is accidentally dropped on its chuck. As in the 13614, there is a built-in tool clip on the back of the unit and brushes are again user-replaceable (although not advised). Balance and feel are excellent, and based on the comments from both the master electrician and his apprentice, function was excellent.

Next came the big-boy Porter Cable 987, which has a whopping 2.4Ah battery in a 19.2V wrapper with 470inch/pounds of torque. Hand feel and balance is excellent, and this model also includes various hand grips to allow for different hand sizes. Especially helpful on all models of the hammer varieties reviewed here are the reversible left or right hand grips.

Bosch
www.boschtools.com
Delta
www.delta.com
Porter Cable
www.portercable.com

Related

Tough Enough?

In the business of sound and video installation, we've all had our share of working with the tools of the trade -- sound meters, volt meters and design programs. But equally crucial to our everyday existence are tools used in a multitude of industries, like wire strippers and crimpers. Selecting the latter type of tools can be as complex a task as any system design. Time and time again, we hear about the "great" new crimper and the $100 must-have, all-in-one tool.

Image placeholder title

Tools of Your Trade

They may not be as interesting or glamorous as the bigticket items of equipment in an AV system, but installation tools—a catch-all term for those useful interconnects, tool kits, and widgets that assist the installation and operation of any system—can not only be cost- and time-savers, but also real life-savers for many technicians in the field.

Image placeholder title

New Products : June 2010

Extron VN-Matrix Series Extron Electronics will exhibit the VN-Matrix 200 Series and VNMatrix 300 Series encoders and decoders for real-time transmission of hig

Image placeholder title

My Generation | An Interview With Fred Shen and Alex Mayo

If you’re a regular reader of SCN, then you’re familiar with the name Shen Milsom & Wilke, the New York-based consulting firm that holds an almost legendary status in the AV industry. The firm has no shortage of experts that we quote on an almost every-issue basis, and they all could have surely lent invaluable expertise on any topic in this issue. However, this being our special Audio Issue, we decided to try something a bit different. Rather than sit down with just any pair of representative experts, we decided to sit down with the firm’s founder, Fred Shen, and invite along one of the company’s most recent hires, the 24-year-old Alex Mayo. This, we thought, would provide unparalleled insight into how the industry has changed since its inception, and also provide an opportunity for two co-workers removed by generations to compare paths into the industry.

Image placeholder title

New Products: September 2010

Juice Goose NXRT And XPRT Series The on-line, double conversion UPS design from Juice Goose found in the NXRT and XPRT series operates connected equipment from the battery 100 percent of the

Unlocking Secrets: Industry Gurus’ Best Practices promo image

Unlocking Secrets: Industry Gurus’ Best Practices

It’s no secret at all that we as individuals have the power to share our wisdom with whom we choose to enlighten. For those of us on the path of enlightenment seeking, it often takes cunning persuasion or subtle ego stroking to extract the wisdom we need from our peers.

Image placeholder title

New Products: October 2010

Tektronix advanced waveform monitors provide high quality, real-time, automated 3Gb/s SDI Eye pattern display and jitter measurements that help broadcasters and network operators effectively diagnose signal problems and help equipment designers and manufacturers reduce time to market of new 3Gb/s SDI products.